Edward F. Carlough was the son of George b. 1878 NYC & Elizabeth, grandson of David J. b. ca 1846 NJ & Elizabeth b. ca 1843,Ire., GGS of Elizabeth b. ca 1823 NY. The family is in Jersey City,NJ 1860, NYC 1870. David is listed as CARLO in NYC 1880. Edward is listed as Francis Edward 1910 Bronx, NY & as Edward in 1920 & 30. He married Florence Sweeney in 1927. They had a daughter Grace b. Sept.1928 Bronx, NY.

I believe Edward's grandmother, David's 1st wife was Elizabeth NEE Carlough, and died between 1880 & 1887, but I need to find her death record.