My Charles Hynicks was definitely in the United States in 1864. He was a volunteer in the Union Army and I have also found a census record for him in in the State of Missouri living with my 2x. Great grandmother in 1870. My problem is the spelling of the name was slightly different each time it was recorded. Names are passed here as they are in Brittain. I know very little about the man. And Family stories can be true but are most likely a little wrong or a lot wrong depending on the truthfulness of the ancestors telling the history. The one you found from 1835 might be correct. I will research more. Thank you for the information.