From my previous post:
"Mother Judith might have remarried in 1854 to a Patrick GEARY?? She seems to have married John HART as a KELLY not O'NEIL - she is probably the Judith O'NEIL who married John KELLY"
When Judith GEARY was admitted to the Newcastle gaol in 1859 her stated ship of arrival was the Hoogley; the same ship that Judith O'NEILL arrived on.