Part of my problem is that LDS shows Catharine as a child of William & Anna and I do find her next to William in 1850 and Catharine's son, Arnold, is administor of the estate of William; however, I have been "told" that Catharine was a Right and married a Right. She is without a husband in 1850 and by 1870 lists herself as widowed. So, like you, am trying to verify and document this paper trail! Any ideas?