I have some info from Census and Obits on these people. The 1910 Census also has a George Goede in the same area is he related. There are also two Charles Goede one born abt 1874 in Minnesota and another in abt 1881 in Dakota Territory. Are they relate. I am guessing the one born in 1881 is the son of Karl. To make matters worse they both seem to have married Emma's. I can send you what I have if you email me donhochstatter@msn.com