I've been confused on this from the very start. Our family state that Jeremiah married Susan King but on Find a Grave, Susan is listed as Asbury's wife and she is buried in Tempy Hutchison's cemetery along with him, his wife and a baby Webster. Family members say that Susan and Jeremiah were divorced but I haven't found any information about that as yet.
I have a Jeremiah Hutchison married 13 Mar 1837 Cape Girardeau Co., MO to Elizabeth Penrod. I also have a Jeremiah married to Mary Jane Williams 7 Nov 1867 Davies, Co., MO.
In 1840 Casey, KY census, Jeremiah is also listed.
1900 Jasper Township, Ozark Co., Mo Susan is listed with her son, Templeton as:
110/111 Hutchison, T.J. Head May 1830 70 yrs. marr. 35 yrs.
Elizabeth wife Oct 1832 68 yrs. marr. 35 yrs.
Mohn, Edward servant
Ledbetter, Matilda servant
Hutchison, Susan mother (can't read the month) 1780 120 yrs. (which there is no way as she died according to her headstone in 1899).

I think there was more than one Jeremiah in this family, has to be with the amount of Jeremiah's that are coming up.