The only lead that I can find is to contact Zion Lutheran Church, on Brandywine Lane, in York, PA. Their website is:
www.zionyork.org.
Their history page on their website states that they originated out of the first Lutheran church that was established "west of the Susquehanna river."(1733). It was known as the: "German Lutheran Congregation, in and near the borough of York, in the county of York, in the State of Pennsylvania."