You're right, the family was Catholic, most still are. I don't have any more information than you do, except that Mayme Fuchs-Gebel wrote me a narrative back in the 1970's. I'm Michael Fuchs, the son of Clifford Fuchs, the son of George Fuchs, the son of Charles A. Fuchs, the son of Andrew and Genevive Fuchs from St. Marys, Penn. Sounds like you made it back a generation further than I did, but I was a teen back in the seventies. Mayme was my grandfather (George Fuchs') older sister.
--Mike