Just a long shot. Did any of your Anderson's marry a Smith. My family was from Canaan Twp. also. Smith's are so hard to find. I lived in Burbank for some time. I believe there were some Anderson's there living at the time.You might want to try and get in touch with the Burbank cemetery to see if you have family there. Burbank, Ohio is just a few miles from Canaan and chester.

Not related. Just a long shot.
Carol