have you traced your Baughman relatives back farther? I have Polly Baughman born in Northumberland County, PA marrying Johannes John Rodebaugh (unknown date) born in Harrisburg, Dauphin County, PA. They came to Summit County mid 1830's and settled in Norton Twp. I am trying to locate their burial place, exact death dates as I have 1842 for Johannes and 1867 for Polly. I have no parents for Polly either. They are my 4th Great paternal grandparents.
Would love to hear from you it is a unusual name and we may be related.