Per the County Probate records, Samuel J. Myton died 17 Mar 1874, age 35, cause of death: unknown, place of death: Yellowbud, born in: Circleville, occupation: blacksmith

Buried in Section 2, lot 43 at Springbank Cemetery; Tombstone reads: Samuel Myton d. 17 Mar 1874 ag. 36y1m13das

I haven't had a chance to check the newspaper records for an obituary; need a few more days.