Thank you for the information. I am going to explore the John & Elizabeth Greenwalt mentioned towards the bottom your reply. I did find a Phebe Greenwalt who married a William Kirby and she died in Tuscarawus County. She may be a sister of John & James/Joshua Greenwalt. An Elizabeth Greenwalt is living with her in the 1850 census Tuscawarus. Now if I can just figure out who this Elizabeth married.