I believe I found her in the Ohio Death Index Online.

http://www.ohiohistory.org/dindex/

REICMHLEY, Sarah J. Death date: //1931, Franklin County
Volume #6706, Certificate #54009

This is most likely her. There are numerous misspellings in the index. You can request a copy of her death certificate.

I did not see her obit listed in the Columbus News Index. If
you are a Columbus Library Card holder you can request a librarian to check for an obit.

jim