I too am a descendent of Andrew Cagg and his wife Julia Ann Risley Henshaw. I can tell you that I found Rebecca and James W Combs in 1860 married, residing in Athens, Athens, Ohio. James W is 25 (born in KY), Rebecca J is 19 (born in OH), and they have 2 children: William L, 4; and Mary B, 1. I also have some Cagg info, please contact me!

Jodi