Abbie Spear was the daughter of John Spear and Lucy Sawyer, who resided in Barton, Tioga NY in 1850. Warren Sawyer, I believe, was the son of Henry Sawyer and Hannah Stevens.
Warren and Abbie are related to our families but not direct ancestors, so I haven't researched them further.

There are two very helpful places you can check for more info. The Town of Caroline Historian is very helpful and resourseful and so is the Candor, Tioga Historical Society- very kind and helpful people. Warren & Abbie resided in Candor in 1860, as did Warren's parents, before moving back to Caroline, Tompkins.