Martha and the other infant were only born a few months apart according to their headstones. I am getting my DNA testing done and maybe that will reveal something. I tentatively put Edmond Scott in the tree with a big asterisk just so I can see if anything comes up with the DNA for either men. I was looking for Native American in this line so perhaps her mom had an affair and just gave the baby the name Scott at first. I imagine it would have been scandalous either way but maybe with the war things were different.