Joanna Thank you so very much for the documents I will read through them now, just to let you know apparently this Selina DENNY has been found on the 1880 Census (as Celina Denis) living in Oconto Wisconsin, this is where Jennie is living also on Jennie (Colliers obit) it mentions a half sister living in Clayton, so looks like this is Lillie. Oh I hope this is all correct. So exciting to get a positive lead. Thanks so so much. Dianna