Hi Aurina many thanks for your reply, I will have a look at the nnyln.net historic paper to see what is said about Angus, who died in 1827.
I don't know if I have two different Benway families here or not as I cannot find My Jennie/Jennet Benway on the 1855 Census, she is on the 1860 I have not looked at the 1865 NY Census either as Family Search is not working for me today.
Anyway trying to sort these Benway's out is a bit of a headache. So it does say that Angus was born in Canada that's interesting. Jennie was born in Carthage on May 9, 1851 and married Charles Collier in 1867 in Antwerp, Jefferson County, not far from Oswego is it. Thanks for your time, this is a hard one let me tell you. Regards and many thanks Dianna