I don't have any information from them while in Ontario NY -- just what I found in the census records and gleaned from others who have indicated they came from there as well. I suspect that Maria Antoinetta, if she was a Garey, her birth location as Ohio in 1850 must be in correct as the family just arrived Meigs years previous to 1850. Was she born in NY? I can't find the Utleys in 1860 but I did find four of their children in Wayne County IL in 1870. I think Maria was in Wayne County IL by 1865 as I see an M.A. Utley in the 1865 IL census (I can't actually see the census record but just the listing of her as I don't subscribe to that level within Ancestry). I think it is interesting that she ended up in Wayne as many families from Meigs County OH ended up there, including some of my Wilsons. Also many families from Meigs went to Winona, MN. Please feel free to contact me at Rwilson7@aol.com
if you would like to chat more. I think it would be interesting to learn how Maria A. Utley came to move to Wayne Co, IL.