Cheers vansicklen1 - I’m almost certain that’s him even with the discrepancies - it’s too close not to be isn’t it? I had seen the info from the indexes at IGG and had a reservation over the age but I know that errors do happen.
Cheers for the directory info by the way. I’ve not managed to make a connection between Daughy/Danahy to my families - in this case O’Neil/Dickers/Ames/Beechinor. They did live on Madison Street so the James at 176 at least offers a possibility from the proximity. I’m going to go through my census files to see if Danahy appears in the same household sometime.
Sorry for the pun but the ‘plot’ thickens!