Can you tell us anything else about Elizabeth? Date and place of death? Childrens' names? Other than possibly Gloversville directories for the early 1900s I don't see other records that are clearly the Elizabeth you are looking for with a date of birth in the 1860s. Have you identified her on any census records? How are you linking the surnames Bennett and Duesler? There is a hit on fultonhistory.com for an Elizabeth known as Betsey Duesler and Edward C. Duesler. It's a foreclosure against them for land in Ephratah. Any possible connection?