That is the right family. Lucretia Vreedenburg Brown was my gggg grandmother. Her daughter Lucretia that married Jesse Cole was my ggg grandmother.
You mentioned that Samuel was their second son. Do you have a complete list of the children and where they were born? I assumed that Samuel was first. Do you know where they married and where they were born? When did they come to the United States? Lucretia says on her land grant papers that she was born in Keneda. Not sure if that is acurate. She also said she was Catholic and we know that to be inacurate.