Yes, it does seem odd that so many of the details are in line with both women. I think I have a picture of the Luciano Trujillo in my family so you can take a look at him. Give me a little time to find it.
One of his physical characteristics was that he had very large hands - which my gggrandmother also had. He had a very fair complexion.
One of his greatgrandaughters, Margie Trujillo has written many family newsletters on the Trujillo family -- it is possible this is a different family. I have not read all the newsletters - but my Mom has copies of them.