Hi, sorry it has taken me so long to get back to you. I didn't see this posting until today. I'm not up to speed on how rootsweb works. I believe my husband has spoken with you before. In re-reading my initial query I find I'm not surprised I've confused you. I should have been more careful. I apologize. Margaret Elizabeth Shipley and Robert Donoho Do not have a daughter named Rebecca (my bad) They have a son named George Milford as you pointed out above. He married Ollie Belle Bruce. It was their daughter Rebecca Donoho that I was referring to. I expect things will make perfect sense to you now.