Found Clarence's birth record - it says both parents born in Marblehead, MA.

Marriage of Patrick and Martha - he was born in Ireland,29 yrs old, parents are Patrick and Ellen
Martha 29 born in Marblehead, parents are Edward B and Mary E 1st marriage for both, Raymond Holiway, Pastor married them in Salem,MA

Martha born Oct 15 1864 Marblehead Parents Edward born in Marblehead, his occupation looks like 'Cordwainer' - no idea what that is, mother is Mary maiden name could be Cloan, Claon also born in Marblehead

Edward and Mary were married May 31, 1843 does not give their ages, something Atkinson(tough to read 1st name)Minister of Universalist Society married them.

Margaret