In the 1860 census, a woman named rutha is seen to be living with Joshua Duncan and family. She is 73 years old. Joshua and his older brothers were each born within one and two years of each other. On the accepted date for henry, Rutha was unborn, on the accepted date for Gideon, she was one year old, on the accepted date for David's birth she was three years old. On the proven date of Champion's birth she was only five years old. She is NOT the mother. At Joshua's birth she was 14, However, she might be mother of Joshua, Will and Freeman, neither is she the mother of Agnes and Martha because on their births she is way past her child bearing years.