Christopher B Taber would have been my 1st cousin, 4 times removed.
Christopher Bewley & Nancy Patterson's daughter, Matilda was my 3rd and also my 4th greatgrandmother.
Some of my Coffman's did move to Indiana, but I could never figure out who Lucy belonged to. Hope you find the marriage certificate for the location. But I am showing most of their children where born in Hardin Co, KY.
I do live in the area the Bewley's lived in. Would be more than happy to help you...if I can.
Gail