After a very extensive search, I have found this is not the family that I am looking for. I have traced this particular family to 1880 & they ended up in St. Louis Mo.

In 1870 (stilll in Indiana)this family includes:
James H- 51
Sarah- 50
James H- 26
Mary-23
David- 19
Clara- 12
Orson T - 9
Alexander 10
Rosa Cunningham - 16
Richard Frazier- 20