I realize it's been just over 2 years since you posted this, and hopefully you haven't changed e-mail addresses.
It's been more than 50 years since I left Oolitic. I graduated in the OHS Class of 1950. I used to swim in some of those quarries around Oolitic, against the will of my father, I might add. I probably knew some of your Italian relatives.
Some were the families of: GARAFOLA; GRANATO; GRECCO; MAGNUS, MUSCATO; ROSS