Starlene, was curious about your posting...I have Benjamin Brinegar in my tree, married to Malinda Shanklin. Their son William married Malinda McCoy. Children I have listed for William and Malinda are Almira, Giles, Mary Addie, Susan and Martha. Their daughter Mary Addie I have married to William Shuart. This sounds like your Anna Elsie Shuart Roberts Patton. Could you please fill me in on Anna's husbands and other children. Thank you so much. ~ Chris