I believe that they could have made a mistake on the spelling
of Cyrus. As they misspelled Pius Schall in the 1880 census.
You could probably get a copy of Cyrus and Ellen's marriage
license in Plymouth. If you type
Hindman@Plymouth.lib.in.us. the librarian gave me a lot of
information. I'm wondering if they have a memorial for him at
the county court house. (For all the Civil War vets)