It sounds like you are related to relatives on Evelyn's side and I am related to relatives on Joey's side. Small world. Anyway, Joey was my uncle. Salvatore Aresco (born l88l in Italy) and Adelaide Sapia (born l885 in Italy) were my grandparents. They came to Ellis Island in l920 with six kids (Joey was born two years later). I will look at the census infor you sent. Thanks for taking the time to do that. The problem with the name Aresco is that it is very common in Italy like Smith is common in the U.S. So there can be many Aresco's but they could all be from different families.
This is very interesting to do. I'm not related to any Sapia's here, tho. They came to live in Middletown, Pearl street first, than College Street (I think it was #67).
Thanks for keeping in touch on this.