The online index for
Cedar Hill Cemetery, Paonia,
Delta County, CO at
http://www.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~codelta/does list an Arthur
Winegar 1859-1939. He's the only
Winegar listed though. I checked the online indexes for the eastern part of Delta County:
Bethlehem Cemetery in Paonia and the
Crawford Cemetery in
Crawford and there were no Winegar's listed there. The
Hotchkiss Cemetery isn't indexed online to my knowledge.
Thinking further on the child that died:
Did the Winegar's come west twice? (lots of folks did). The Census records shows:
1900
Cook Co, IL Nora--mother of one child, none living.
1910
Delta Co, CO Mother of one child, none living.
Per census, they married between c1894-95
Per census, the child died before Jan 1 1900
On Jan 1 1900 they are listed in
Cook Co, IL.
Possible match:
The IL Statewide Death Index pre1916 lists a
Winegar,
Emery died 24 Feb 1899 in Chicago,
Cook Co, age 5yrs.
Hope there's something helpful in all of this.
Happy searching!