Search for content in message boards

Mary Goodale Fish / Pease - pilgrim era maiden names?

Mary Goodale Fish / Pease - pilgrim era maiden names?

Posted: 9 Oct 2014 9:27PM GMT
Classification: Query
Surnames: Goodale, Goodall, Pease, Fish, Fyshe, Fiche
My many times great grandfather Jonathan Fish & his two brothers immigrated to Sandwich, Cape Cod Massachusetts in 1637. He married a Mary Goodale & they had 3 sons, John, Nathan, & Samuel. I have found a good bit of information on the Fish family, but am trying to find more on his wife's. I have found information on a Mary Goodale's immigration at age 4 with her parents Robert & Katherine, as well as a death record for a Mary Goodale/Pease in Salem, Mass in 1669. It's possible these are all the same person if Mary first married Jonathan Fish & later John Pease. I have seen this in several public trees on ancestry.com but haven't found any documents or evidence besides this.

Does anyone have any information or suggestions of where to look? John Pease married a Mary Goodale, not Mary Fish, would she have gone back to her maiden name after her husband's death, at least in record keeping?

Re: Mary Goodale Fish / Pease - pilgrim era maiden names?

Posted: 19 Oct 2014 1:21PM GMT
Classification: Query
According to published FISH and PEASE researchers, it wouldn't be possible for the two Marys to be the same woman, the timelines and their locations conflict (see the attached).

I also found this, "Gershom Moore married Mary the widow of Jonathan Fish, leaving sons Gershom and Jonathan".

That was found in:
The annals of Newtown in Queens County, New-York : containing its history from its first settlement, together with many interesting facts concerning the adjacent towns : also, a particular account of numerous Long Island families now spread over this and various other states of the Union
New York: D. Fanshaw, 1852, 441 pgs.; pages 327, 328

I am not related.
Attachments:
per page

Find a board about a specific topic