HI, I agree that Robert the schoolmaster was married to Janet and Christian. I have a chart written by a relative from memory and stories from family and she shows them both as his family.I have to think about all the info you just sent as they used John, Robert etc. so often that I get my years and people confused.In my research Bethia is shown as Bethia Cadder Main but I wonder also why she wouldn't have lived with her father. My chart states that he had 19 children but I haven't added your info yet. He married Christian June 26, 1830 New Monkland.Lynne